September 3, 2008

Introduction to "Second Witness" with Brant Gardner

Likening With Care, Part 1 
 

Second Witness: Analytical & Contextual Commentary on the Book of Mormon by Brant Gardner is the most comprehensive commentary on the Book of Mormon to date. True, there are many commentaries  available from such authors as Sidney Sperry, George Reynolds and Janne Sjödahl, Hugh Nibley, Daniel Ludlow, David Ridges, Joseph Fielding McConkie and Robert Millett, Ed Pinegar, Monte S. Nyman and others. In addition, articles and publications on the Book of Mormon are legion, perhaps the most extensive being the work published by the Foundation for Ancient Research and Mormon Studies. What justified another commentary?

Gardner has taken the best aspects of nearly all previous commentary attempts into account, incorporating an impressive amount of former studies with his own insights as a scholar of early Mesoamerica and believer in the Book of Mormon. He sees Book of Mormon commentaries as falling in two "rough" categories of approach:

Those that concentrate on the devotional aspects of religion (and which tend to be ahistorical) and those that attempt to deal with the text in its historical context. Most LDS commentaries have been necessarily heavy on the devotional and light on the historical because there is no official geography of the Book of Mormon. I wanted to brave the wilds and use the best current description of where the Book of Mormon took place to see if that cultural background and time could increase our understanding of the events in the text.1
He is quick to point out at the outset of volume one that he accepts the Book of Mormon "as a translation of an ancient text" and that he intended "to inquire into the process of Joseph Smith's translation or how the text fits into the ancient Old and New Worlds. I do not attempt to prove or disprove it but to understand it."2 Thus, not only does Gardner utilize much former scholarship, he is not averse to challenging former scholarship at times, even from those whom he sees as pioneers or experts in the field such as John Sorenson and Hugh Nibley, or even LDS leaders such as Joseph Fielding Smith.3 He is also not shy about challenging common LDS assumptions about the text, or admitting problematic aspects; all done in an overall tone which shouldn't threaten the reader, but rather invite personal reflection. Gardner's is a comprehensive look at the spiritual, theological, cultural and historical context of the book.

I call Gardner's overall approach "likening with care," in reference to Nephi's assertion, "I did liken all scriptures unto us, that it might be for our profit and learning" (1 Nephi 19:23). Latter-day Saints have had a tendency to read the Book of Mormon through a modern lens, noting Mormon's statement "I speak unto you as if ye were present, and yet ye are not. But behold, Jesus Christ hath shown you unto me, and I know your doing" (Mormon 8:35). Most Book of Mormon commentaries attempt to help readers better understand how the text can apply in everyday gospel living today. This approach is beneficial and important, and Gardner does not avoid it. However, he explained in the Introduction to volume 1:
The people of the Book of Mormon lived in two different worlds. The first was the Old World. For a short time, the text is anchored in both space and time by a known location (Jerusalem) and known events...When the story moves to the New World, the Book of Mormon becomes a text without a context...Without the human context provided by continuity of place and time, we increase the interpretive disjunction with which we frequently misread the Bible, even with its rich context...
We tend to read the Bible and the Book of Mormon as though people just like us wrote them. We assume that their concerns were our concerns and that the things that we care about most were precisely the things that they also cared about most. This reading backward of our world into theirs does not diminish our ability to discern spiritual value in the Bible or the Book of Mormon...
One of this commentary's goals is to recontextualize the Book of Mormon so that it is easier to understand that it is about real people and real places...4
In focusing more in a New World setting (especially after the book of Mosiah5), Gardner is able to illuminate cultural aspects previously unseen in print. Rather than finding the Book of Mormon in Mesoamerica, he sought to discover Mesoamerica in the Book of Mormon, and isn't afraid to challenge long-held opinions on various issues. Remarkably, he is able to do this with what Jeff Needle from the Association For Mormon Letters rightly called "generosity." Needle pinpointed Gardner's charitable tone:
...his commentary offers the reader something that other commentaries may not: a wide generosity in how one can understand the message of the Book of Mormon. Such generosity is rare on both sides of the debate -- either you're for it, or you're against it. Gardner stands in the gap and offers both sides a way approach the book in a constructive manner.6 
With six full-sized volumes the set stands at a formidable $199, but readers can also opt to buy volumes individually, the first priced at about $32 at the FAIR bookstore. Second Witness is the touchstone for all contemporary scholarship on the Book of Mormon. What Richard Bushman's Rough Stone Rolling is to Joseph Smith, Gardner's Second Witness is to the Book of Mormon; a watershed event in scholarly LDS publication history.


_________________________________________________
Next in the "Likening With Care" we'll discuss the origin and destiny of the series, including the logistics of  writing, designing, and publishing such a complex work.  


FOOTNOTES

[1]
Other than when noted, Gardner's comments in this series are from personal e-mails from Gardner in my possession.

[2]
Gardner, Second Witness, Vol. 1, p. vii.

[3]
The book is full of goodies from other scholars. For example, Gardner closely follows Royal Skousen's important Analysis of Textual Variants of the Book of Mormon and other such studies to carefully note interesting, important, or problematic word variants among different editions of the Book of Mormon, in addition to noting the original format of the book, which wasn't divided into our current chapter/verse configuration until 1879.

[4]
ibid. 2-3.

[5]
As a specialist in studies of Mesoamerica, Gardner said the first two volumes were the most daunting of the series, "with 2 Nephi [as] a petrifying hurdle before I actually started":
1 Nephi and the Isaiah texts are Old World stuff, and I an a New World guy. I think that I represented others' scholarship in 1 and 2 Nephi, but there was more of their work and less original work. Starting in vol. 3 we get serious into the New World, and I think there are more places where I offer a new perspective rather than a rehash of previous scholarship. Both are useful, but I am always more interested in the new stuff.
[6]
Jeffery Needle, "Gardner, Second Witness: Analytical and Contextual Commentary on the Book of Mormon. Volume 1: First Nephi- Review," Association For Mormon Letters Discussion Board, March 30, 2008.

28 comments:

Kent said...

Blair,

I looked at these books and was interested, but now I am excited! Thanks for the review.

Sione said...

Can you lend me $30 please :-)

SIone

LifeOnaPlate said...

Kent:
np.

Sione:
I cannot. :(

But you won't regret buying this series. It's well worth it.

Kent said...

The Provo Library just acquired them!

LifeOnaPlate said...

As well it should!

LifeOnaPlate said...

Part two will be posted on monday. If anyone has questions they'd like to ask Brant about the series, the BoM, etc., leave them here in the comment section for me, or click the "contact me" link on the main page.

Reed said...

I'd like to know what Brant thinks of Ostler's "The Book of Mormon as a Modern Expansion of an Ancient Source."

LifeOnaPlate said...

Thanks for the question, Reed. Gardner's thoughts on Ostler's expansion theory are coming up in the series.

Ranveer Patil said...

This is great do you have a catologue if so I would love one to share with friends and family.
ICC T20 World Cup 2016 Schedule PDF

Download

Australia vs India 2016 Squad

jasmine kaur said...

T20 Worldcup 2016
T20 Worldcup 2016 Live
T20 Worldcup 2016 Teams
T20 Worldcup 2016 Schedule
ICC T20 Worldcup 2016
T20 Worldcup 2016
T20 Worldcup 2016 Live
T20 Worldcup 2016 Teams
T20 Worldcup 2016 Schedule
ICC T20 Worldcup 2016

jasmine kaur said...

Super Bowl commercials 2016
best super bowl commercials
2016 Super Bowl Commercials
Super Bowl Commericals
Super Bowl halftime show 2016
Super Bowl 50
super bowl 50 tickets
super bowl halftime show
Super Bowl halftime show 2016
Super Bowl 50
super bowl 50 tickets
super bowl halftime show
Super Bowl commercials 2016
best super bowl commercials
2016 Super Bowl Commercials
Super Bowl Commericals

Preet Kaur said...

live
t20worldcup live
icc t20worldcup 2016
icc t20worldcup 2016 live
icc t20worldcup highlights
worldcup live
20-20 World Cup 2016 Schedule
Happy Holi SMS in Hindi
Happy Holi SMS in English
Happy Holi Wishes 2016
Happy Holi Greetings 2016
Happy Holi Date 2016
Happy Holi Whatsaap Status
Happy Holi Facebook Status
Happy Holi Facebook Cover
happy holi 2016 wishes
Happy Holi Recipes

Satish Kumar said...

tamil kadhal kavithaigal in tamil language

Anhi Dey said...

Mother’s Day 2016 Gift Ideas
Mothers Day 2016 Gift Ideas

Social Gtf said...


nice article.......
Earthcon Sanskriti
Earthcon Sanskriti Noida
Earthcon Sanskriti Noida Extension





Kuttu Das said...

Great article. Want to know about Best Smart Home Security Systems? visit this site

Kuttu Das said...

Do you want to know Pokemon on iPhone? Visit my site

Somnath Roy said...

Want to watch the Euro Cup matches live from your home,just check Euro Cup Live Stream

Khushi Sharma said...

Nice Article , I also have some topics visit them..............
Happy Friendship Day
Happy Friendship Day Quotes
Friendship Day Quotes
Friendship Day Images
Friendship Day Messages
Friendship Day SMS
Best Whatsapp Status
15th August Whatsapp Status
Friendship Day Whatsapp Status
Friendship Whatsapp Status
Happy Friendship Day Whatsapp Status
Happy Independence Day Whatsapp Status
Love Status for Whatsapp
Nice Whatsapp Status
Happy Birthday Whatsapp Status
Funny Whatsapp Status
Cool Whatsapp Status
Good Morning Whatsapp Status
Good Night Whatsapp Status
Best Whatsapp DP
Whatsapp Profile Picture
Parents Day Whatsapp Status
Happy Parents Day
Raksha Bandhan Whatsapp Status
Happy Raksha Bandhan Status
Rakhi Whatsapp Status

Rimi Arora said...

Hi i was browsing your blog and i found it really interesting! i too have a
friendship quotes
friendship day
friendship day images
happy friendship day
happy friendship day images
friendship day quotes
images of friendship day
when is friendship day
friendship day messages
friend ship day
happy friendship day quotes
national friendship day
friendship day pics
friendship day wallpaper
friendship day photos
friendship day sms
happy friends day
friend ship day images
friendship day wishes
happy friendship quotes
friendship day pictures
Whatsapp Status
Friends Whatsapp Status
Friendship Day Whatsapp Status
Funny Whatsapp Status
Cool Whatsapp Status
Good Morning Whatsapp Status
Love Status For Whatsapp
Nice Whatsapp Status
Rakhi Whatsapp Status
Raksha Bandhan Whatsapp Status
Best Whatsapp DP
Best Whatsapp Profile Pictures

Rimi Arora said...

Hi i was browsing your blog and i found it really interesting! i too have a
Galaxy Blue Sapphire Plaza
Galaxy Blue Sapphire Noida Extension
Galaxy Blue Sapphire
Galaxy Blue Sapphire Plaza Noida

Rimi Arora said...

Nice Article , I also have some topics visit them..............
couples halloween costumes ideas
funny halloween costumes ideas
halloween costumes Ideas for women
couples halloween costume ideas
cute halloween costumes
family halloween costumes
halloween ideas
good halloween costumes
halloween pumpkin
Happy Navratri 2016
Happy Navratri Images
Happy Navratri
Happy Navratri Wishes
Whatsapp Status
Independence Day Whatsapp Status
Best Whatsapp Status
15 August Whatsapp Status
Friendship Day Whatsapp Status
Good Morning Whatsapp Status
Cool Whatsapp Status
Friends Whatsapp Status
Funny Whatsapp Status
Good Evening Whatsapp Status
Good Night Whatsapp Status
Happy Birthday Whatsapp Status
Happy Friendship Day Whatsapp Status
Happy Independence Day Whatsapp Status
Happy Parents Day Whatsapp Status
Love Whatsapp Status
Love Status For Whatsapp
Nice Whatsapp Status
Rakhi Whatsapp Status
Raksha Bandhan Whatsapp Status
Best Whatsapp Profile Pictures
Best Whatsapp DP

Rimi Arora said...

Nice Article , I also have some topics visit them..............
India’s Independence Day
Independence Day India
15 August Images
15 August speech
15 August Songs
15 August Quotes
15 August Whatsapp Status
15 August Facebook Status
15 August Shayari
15 August Photos
15 August Messages
15 August SMS
15 August Wishes
15 August Pictures
15 August Wallpaper
Happy Independence Day
Happy Independence Day 2016
Happy Independence Day Images
Happy Independence Day Wishes
Happy Independence Day Messages
Happy Independence Day Quotes
Happy Independence Day Songs
Happy Independence Day Bhashan
Happy Independence Day Parade
RIO Olympics 2016 Schedule
RIO 2016 Tickets
RIO Olympics 2016 Medal Tally
RIO Olympics 2016
Olympics 2016
La Tomatina
Tomatina Festival
Tomato Festival Spain
Tomatina Festival
La Tomatina 2016
Halloween Costumes
Halloween Costumes Idea
Happy Halloween Costumes
Happy Halloween 2016 ideas
Happy Halloween Ideas
halloween store
halloween express
halloween decoration Ideas
sexy halloween costumes ideas

Rimi Arora said...

Nice Article , I also have some topics visit them..............
Happy Raksha Bandhan
Happy Raksha Bandhan Images
Happy Raksha Bandhan Wishes
Rakhi Images
Raksha Bandhan
Raksha Bandhan 2016
Raksha Bandhan Greetings
Raksha Bandhan Images
Raksha Bandhan Messages
Raksha Bandhan Photos
Raksha Bandhan Pics
Raksha Bandhan Pictures
Raksha Bandhan SMS
Raksha Bandhan Status
Raksha Bandhan Wallpaper
Raksha Bandhan Wishes
Janmashtami Images
Happy Janmashtami
Krishna Janmashtami
Krishna Janmashtami 2016
Krishna Janmashtami Celebration
Krishna Janmashtami Facebook Status
Krishna Janmashtami Images
Krishna Janmashtami Messages
Krishna Janmashtami Photos
Krishna Janmashtami Pics
Krishna Janmashtami Pictures
Krishna Janmashtami Quotes
Krishna Janmashtami SMS
Krishna Janmashtami Wallpaper
Krishna Janmashtami Whatsapp Status
Krishna Janmashtami Wishes

艾丰 said...

jianbin0816
pandora outlet
air jordan 4
nike air huarache
polo ralph lauren
timberland shoes
nike outlet store
coach outlet online
nike roshe
adidas nmd
michael kors outlet
cheap oakley sunglasses
cheap ugg boots
fitflops shoes
ugg boots
coach outlet
ralph lauren uk
ugg outlet
moncler outlet store
michael kors handbags
michael kors outlet online
michael kors handbags
michael kors handbags clearance
mulberry outlet
hollister uk
louis vuitton pas cher
ferragamo shoes
reebok shoes
michael kors outlet
cheap ray ban sunglasses
cheap nfl jerseys
ugg boots
louis vuitton outlet
ralph lauren polo
yeezy boost
michael kors outlet clearance

dong dong23 said...

ugg boots
michael kors outlet
coach outlet store online clearances
coach outlet
michael kors
nba jerseys
coach outlet
burberry outlet
toms outlet
true religion outlet
christian louboutin outlet
adidas originals shoes
true religion outlet
rolex watches
michael kors handbags
mont blanc pens for sale
oakley sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet
adidas originals
ugg boots
air jordan pas cher
designer handbags
coach outlet store online
replica watches
replica watches
uggs outlet
ralph lauren outlet
dallas mavericks jerseys
coach outlet
celine
uggs on sale
tommy hilfiger outlet
louis vuitton outlet
adidas nmd
new york knicks jerseys
canada goose
nike trainers
coach outlet store online
kobe shoes 11
coach outlet
20168.18wengdongdong

Somnath Brahma said...


Want to know about National Cat day that is dedicated to cats, just check out Happy National Cat Day
and update yourself with all the information you need

harrymackay said...

good Thus this video game can be first of all released check this website this experience will become useful in wrecking your opponents tower system. Clash Royale for PC App Download nice.

Post a Comment

All views are welcome when shared respectfully. Use a name or consistent pseudonym rather than "anonymous." Deletions of inflammatory posts will be noted. Thanks for joining the conversation.