November 17, 2009

Early authoritative efforts to curb "badly written" LDS publications

A transcript of Parley P. Pratt's "Regulations for the Publishing Department of the Latter-day Saints in the East" (1845).

"The views expressed herein are the responsibility of the author and do not necessarily represent the position of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints."
This disclaimer is found in most unofficial Church-themed publications, but it wasn't always so. Most (if not all) early publications by members of the Church didn't include such disclaimers until after the death of Joseph Smith. Interestingly, centralization of producing Church literature was motivated by finances as much as anything else. Financial considerations have been an important part of LDS publishing ever since Martin Harris mortgaged his farm for money used to print the Book of Mormon. From the very start, Latter-day Saints took full advantage of early 19th-century print culture to spread the gospel.

For example, in 1831 Joseph Smith received a revelation creating a Literary Firm to take charge of publishing revelations and receiving remuneration therefrom.1 Missionaries produced their own tracts to warn of the impending Millennium and counter anti-Mormon accusations.2 Several LDS newspapers disseminated news, sermons, revelations, political positions, birth, death and marriage notices, and other items of interest.3

Historian David J. Whittaker has analyzed early Mormon pamphleteering to shed light on how the Church begun to form a more centralized (or "official") voice. Among other significant factors, flooding the market with LDS tracts decreased the sales of works by apostles like Parley P. and Orson Pratt. Money that could have been better spent to fund construction of the Nauvoo Temple went to pamphlets that simply borrowed from earlier pamphlets or presented poorly-executed scriptural proof-texts. In 1845 Parley P. Pratt published "the first attempt to establish guidelines for publishing in the early Church."4 Following the death of Joseph Smith, leaders of the Church tried to keep things together using Church publications to promote unity, oppose schismatics, and to more effectively use tithing and other resources. Pratt's call for correlation was published in the New York Prophet in early January 1845 and reprinted in the Times and Seasons a week and a half later. Pratt emphasized several reasons for centralization including improving quality, decreasing redundancy and oversupply, and making better use of "vast sums" he felt should be used to help complete the temple. Another slightly understated—but perhaps most important factor—was the question of succession. Pratt noted that the only current "emporiums of light, truth, and news" are those "appointed by the Twelve" and "published by authority." Tellingly, the article directly following Pratt's also demonstrates the use of print media to warn members of the Church about schismatics. "BEWARE OF IMPOSTORS" cautions readers against Daniel and Nancy Botsford's "improper and erroneous efforts" to take advantage of charitable saints, in addition to their "reporting certain slanderous tales respecting the leaders and church at Nauvoo."5

The following is a full transcript of Pratt's article. It's an interesting glimpse at one of the initial steps toward what we might call "correlation."


Dear Brethren:-- Are you not all aware that very many, if not all, of our men, women and children are turning authors, and publishing works purporting to be illustrative of the doctrine of the saints. Some of them are badly written, and some of them are mixed with error, and very many of them which are true and useful are borrowed, in part or in full, from our standard works which are already extant, and therefore, these new vamped pieces or tracts are not particularly needed; besides, there is another consideration—vast sums are expended by men who have but little experience in publishing, and perhaps pay double for the paper and printing, and all this into the hands of those who feel no interest in our cause.

In this way thousands of dollars are drawn from the saints and from the elders, while the temple cause is neglected. All these things are out of order and must come to an end; or else those men who have experience, and whose business it is to write and publish the truth; will have to cease and have no more to do with publishing. For they, and the others too, cannot find support in the business so as to make the works pay for themselves.

We have now three departments, duly appointed by the presidency of the church, viz: the Nauvoo office, under the management of Mr. J. Taylor, the English department, under Brother W. Woodruff, and the New York publishing department, now committed to my charge.

These three great emporiums of light, truth, and news, are quite sufficient until the work enlarges and other similar establishments are appointed by the Twelve.

The church, therefore, is hereby instructed not to patronize, purchase, or support any publication pertaining to our cause, except they emanate from one of these three offices, and under the sanction and authority of those who are appointed to manage this matter.

Let the books, tracts, periodicals, pamphlets, &c. of Mr. B. Winchester and others no longer be patronized by the saints.6 Let the ‘Times and Seasons,’ ‘Neighbor,’ ‘Millennial Star,’ and ‘Prophet’ be well supported, together with the standard Hymn Book, Book of Mormon, and such other works as are, or may be, published by authority as approved standards; and this will be all the church is able to do at present. Considering the tithings for the temple, and the duties of charity and hospitality which are required of them.

The public are also cautioned that no works will be considered as a standard by the saints concerning their principles except they are published by the authorities above named.

New York, Jan. 1st, 1845.

[Editor's note:] We shall second the “regulations” of Elder Pratt: there is nothing like order in the kingdom of God.7


See Doctrine and Covenants section 70; Steven C. Harper, Making Sense of the Doctrine and Covenants: A Guided Tour Through Modern Revelations, (Deseret Book, 2008), pp. 243-246. See also the entry for "The United Firm" at Later efforts to publish canonical books were contingent on approval from Joseph Smith or other leading authorities. For example, Brigham Young deferred to Smith's judgment on publishing an edition of the Book of Mormon in England in 1840, though it seems he acted first and asked second (see Leonard J. Arrington, Brigham Young: American Moses, University of Illinois Press [1986], pp. 81, 84, 89). In 1839 Parley P. Pratt requested to publish an edition in the eastern states but was advised against it (see Parley P. Pratt to Joseph Smith, 22 November 1839; Hyrum Smith to Parley P. Pratt, 22 December 1839, in the Joseph Smith Collection, Church Archives; David J. Whittaker, "Early Mormon Pamphleteering," Journal of Mormon History Vol. 4 [1977], p.43).

These include works from leading Latter-day Saints like the Pratt brothers in addition to other missionaries who published on a smaller scale. Whittaker, ibid., pp. 35-49.

Latter-day Saint newspapers preceding Pratt's 1845 call for correlation included The Evening and Morning Star (June 1832-July 1833), Latter Day Saints' Messenger and Advocate (October 1834-March 1837), Elders' Journal (October-November 1837), Times and Seasons (November 1839-February 1846) and the Millennial Star (1840-1970). More secular-oriented papers included the Nauvoo Wasp which became the Nauvoo Neighbor (May 1833-October 1845), and the New York Prophet or The Prophet (August 1844-February 1845). The Gospel Reflector, published by Benjamin Winchester, was the first "independent" Mormon newspaper (January-June 1841). John E. Page also published two short-lived periodicals, Gospel Light (1843), and People's Organ (1844).

Whittaker, ibid., p. 44.

Calvin C. Pendleton, "BEWARE OF IMPOSTORS," Times and Seasons 6 (15 January 1845): 778.

Benjamin Winchester was an early convert to Mormonism who participated in Zion's Camp and became a member of the first Quorum of the Seventy. He was president of a large branch in Philadelphia and was one of the most prolific non-Apostle publishers in the early Church. He published five single-volume works and twelve issues of his periodical, Gospel Reflector. He was excommunicated in 1844 and despite being singled out in Pratt's article his publications evidently were not the direct cause of his excommunication. He became a follower of Sidney Rigdon during the so-called "succession crisis" after Joseph Smith was killed and his publications were marginalized by Parley Pratt on behalf of the Apostles. Winchester eventually left Mormonism altogether. See Whittaker, ibid., p. 43; "East of Nauvoo: Benjamin Winchester and the Early Mormon Church," Journal of Mormon History 21:2 (Fall 1995), pp. 31-83.

Parley P. Pratt, “Regulations For the Publishing Department of the Latter-day Saints in the East,” New York Prophet 1 (4 January 1845): 2; reprinted in Times and Seasons 6 (15 January 1845): 778.


Ben said...

There is actually a much deeper, and more revealing, reason for this notice of regulation. This was published right at the crux of the succession crisis, and one of PP's duties was to limit the voice of dissenting voices (most notably Winchester, who is specifically mentioned here). By publishing this notice, Pratt was instructing all the Eastern saints to only trust sources coming from those associated with the Quorum of the Twelve. Indeed, Pratt's ability to somewhat limit the influence of competing voices of Rigdonites (like Winchester) and soon-to-be Strangites (like Adams) was a significant move for the 12.

You hint at this reason briefly in your intro, but I personally think it was the dominant reason and should be acknowledged as such. The other reasons were indeed present, but they were mainly appendages and results of the impulse to silence opposing voices.

BHodges said...

My hint about schismatics was a set up for a second post, but it's actually better (and easier) to include it all in one. I added in the bits about the subsequent "impostors" article and the use of print media to alert members about various schismatic folk.

J. Stapley said...

I enjoyed the write-up, BHodges.

BHodges said...

Thanks J.

Mushtaq ahmed said...

activate axis bank mobile banking
activate andhra bank mobile baking
activate canara bank mobile banking
activate corporation bank mobile banking
activate syndicate bank mobile banking
activate central bank mobile banking
activate dena bank mobile banking
activate union bank mobile banking
activate yes bank mobile banking
activate uco bank mobile banking
activate obc mobile banking
activate vijaya bank mobile banking
activate idbi mobile banking
activate citi bank mobile banking
activate kotak mobile banking
hdfc net banking
icici net banking
axis net banking
andhra net banking
canara net banking
corporation net banking
syndicate net banking
central bank net banking
dena bank net banking
union bank net banking
yes bank net banking
uco bank net banking
obc net banking
vijaya bank net banking
idbi bank net banking
citi bank net banking
bob net banking
kotak net banking

Mushtaq ahmed said...

apply hdfc loan against property

Mushtaq ahmed said...

change bob net banking password

Post a Comment

All views are welcome when shared respectfully. Use a name or consistent pseudonym rather than "anonymous." Deletions of inflammatory posts will be noted. Thanks for joining the conversation.