September 29, 2008

Method and Skepticism (and Quetzalcoatl...)

Likening With Care, Part 10
In a recent online discussion an inquirer called "JeffM" questioned the reliability of LDS scholars:

When a Mormon scholar does his work, does he set his testimony (i.e. witness from God) aside so as to be able to consider evidence both for and against the position he wants to support? If so, fine. If not, then the search for evidence actually becomes a search only to confirm what is already "known".1
Mormon scholar Brant Gardner responded with his views on this question, noting his discoveries regarding Quetzalcoatl as illustrative of how his beliefs affect his approach:
I can't answer for anyone else, but I can answer for myself. When I began working on Quetzalcoatl mythology, I started with the assumption that I would confirm the standard LDS interpretation. I soon found that the evidence was quite complicated and that in the end it did not confirm the standard LDS interpretation of Quetzalcoatl. That required me to restructure the way I saw the Book of Mormon relative to that particular issue (and to understand that it has nothing to do with the Book of Mormon, so it was a restructuring of folklore more than scripture). I never laid aside my testimony, never picked it up again. Nevertheless, I doubt that there are any secular Mesoamericanists who would disagree with my analysis.

On the other hand, I applied the same methodological rigor to placing the Book of Mormon in a Mesoamerican context. I did it with the same willingness to a conclusion that doesn't fit, but I found that while there were (as with Quetzalcoatl) some ideas that didn't fit, much did. However, I sincerely doubt that Mesoamericanists would agree with my analysis. The difference lies totally in the realm of their assumed approach to religion, and not in the data.2
Many Mormons are likely familiar with the concept of some Mesoamericans believing in a "white god" who appeared and promised to return. For some, this has been considered incidental confirmation of the Book of Mormon account of Christ visiting the New World. Gardner self-deprecatingly admits to having had a "fixation" on Quetzalcoatl and has spent years researching the myth. Expecting to find some ties to the Book of Mormon, and despite his belief that the Book of Mormon is an ancient text, Gardner's studies resulted in his rejecting a connection between the Nephite record and Quetzalcoatl. His discoveries and analysis can be found on his website here.

JeffM's argument that a Mormon scholar's beliefs can influence the results of their findings is certainly true, but it overlooks the concept of all data being theory laden:
[JeffM] A genuine search for answers looks for both confirming and disconfirming evidence in an effort to determine if the hypothesis is valid.

[Gardner] Not quite. Almost all hypotheses have potentially disconfirming data. They cannot be ignored. However, a good historical hypothesis may stand against possible disconfirming data if (and only if) those data are explained inside a coherent and acceptable framework. Hard scientists are quite familiar with some conclusions that don't fit, but which may be explained by errors in the experiment, or other factors.
The point is that disconfirming data must be considered, but the fact that one person assumes that it is disconfirming does not make it so. The best theories account for the disconfirming data as well as the confirming data. What is dangerous is to ignore disconfirming data.
JeffM also assumes that Mormon studies are generally unreliable or dubious if written by Mormons:
[JeffM] Outsiders like myself are concerned about disconfirming evidence that Mormon scholars don't see because it "can't" exist.

[Gardner] Quite to the contrary. I don't know of any of the LDS scholars who fit that description. They are abundantly aware of all of the [currently available] data. The question you must ask yourself is why you assume the data to be disconfirming without doing the work that tells you whether or not it really is.
Non-LDS sociologist Rodney Stark commented on this subject in his 2005 book The Rise of Mormonism:
Mormon liberals often concern themselves with conflicts between the Book of Mormon and archaeological research. Claims that Lehi and his followers found wild cows and horses do not seem to square with the fossil record. Of course, Christian liberals have long been expressing similar concerns about the biblical account of the Creation and the flood. But if these things worry liberals, it must be noticed that tens of millions of evangelical Christians are not troubled about the flood, nor are millions of Latter-day Saints worried about Lehi's horses.
The problem for both Christian and Mormon liberals is that they inevitably project their inability to believe on everyone else. Mormon liberals worry about disconfirmations of the Book of Mormon because they don't really believe that it an ancient and inspired scripture but think that it is something Joseph Smith composed, consciously or otherwise. Orthodox Latter-day Saints, believing the book to the Word of God, are not only able to accommodate some discrepancies but also fully expect archaeologists to find evidence in support of scripture, which is why the church has supported a considerable amount of New World archeology.3
In the meantime, there are many LDS scholars who are not afraid to frankly admit conflicts or problematic aspects regarding the Book of Mormon in comparison to current archaeological data. This approach was embodied by early LDS scholar and Seventy B.H. Roberts, who produced a rigorous critique of the Book of Mormon. During his investigation he explained:
Let me say once for all, so as to avoid what might otherwise call for repeated explanation, that what is herein set forth does not represent any conclusions of mine. This report herewith submitted is what it purports to be, namely a "study of Book of Mormon origins," for the information of those who ought to know everything about it pro et con, as well as that which has been produced against it, and that which may be produced against it.
I am taking the position that our faith is not only unshaken but unshakable in the Book of Mormon, and therefore we can look without fear upon all that can be said against it.4
Brant Gardner is a scholar intent on responsibly using the current data available in his study of the Book of Mormon from both LDS and non-LDS sources. As his findings on Quetzalcoatl demonstrate, he is not averse to following the data where it leads him as best he can despite his religious convictions; an attitude demonstrated throughout his new Book of Mormon commentary Second Witness.


FOOTNOTES:
[1]
JeffM, "Concern about conclusions of Mormon scholars," MormonApologetics.org , Sept. 18, 2008.

[2]
Brant Gardner, "Concern about conclusions of Mormon scholars," MormonApologetics.org, Sept. 18, 2008.

[3]
Rodney Stark, The Rise of Mormonism, Columbia University Press (2005), 120.

[4]
B. H. Roberts to the First Presidency and the Quorum of the Twelve, March 1923. LDS scholar Kevin Christensen has written several papers discussing issues of skepticism, bias, and research methods in studies on the Book of Mormon. For example, see "Truth and Method: Reflections on Dan Vogel's Approach to the Book of Mormon ," FARMS Review 16:1, pp. 287-354.

105 comments:

Anonymous said...

I just read the introductory chapters of "Second Witness" and I am in awe. I'm going to find a way to buy each book over the next year while I borrow them from the library to digest them immediately. I will be using this set as a reference for the rest of my life.

BHodges said...

I see the series as the most important commentary on the BoM to date. I am also buying them in turn as often as occasion will permit.

rameumptom said...

In listening to Brant speak in the past, I do agree that the Quetzalcoatl tie with the book of Mormon is tenuous at best - at least for many of the issues that some attempt to link them together with.
However, that does not necessarily dismiss all stories about a white god from elsewhere. The stories of Viracocha, which generally are ignored by LDS scholars, include a story where the sun did not shine for many days. After those days of prayer and fear, the sun arose from Lake Titicaca. Viracocha appeared about noon that day, and spent several days among the Inca, performing miracles and teaching. He left over the ocean waves, promising to return again.
Such a story does not have a strong Biblical link, as do the tenuous stories of Quetzalcoatl, but does potentially link to 3 Nephi 8-11.

BHodges said...

Congrats to Larry Poulson, who marks the 20,000th visit to the website Life On Gold Plates!

Unknown said...

Congrats, Larry.

rameumptom:

It is very hard to know how to use native legends. The Quetzalcoatl material is one of the few data sets with enough information to begin to sort out what is pre-contact and what isn't.

I don't know what to say about the Viracocha tales. They sound interesting, but so did the Quetzalcoatl tales before I knew more about them. The rest of the problem comes from the problem of time and space. There is no geographic correlation that I know of that can reasonably place the Book of Mormon that far south. Therefore, we have the question of how such a tale could be connected to the Book of Mormon.

The element of the Viracocha tale, the darkness before the rising of the sun, fits into native mythological categories even without a connection to the Book of Mormon, so it is very difficult to take as a connection at face value. Much more would have to be done to be able to posit it as some kind of remembrance.

rameumptom said...

Brant,
I agree there is no "proof" in the pudding regarding any Mesoamerican legends.
As for being an Incan legend, there is evidence of trade between Mayans and Incans. Traditions and stories are often traded between peoples.
Second, who is to say that Christ only appeared to one group? The Book of Mormon has the destructions occurring in the first month (3 Nephi 8:5), and Christ's appearance to the Nephites in the last month of the year (3 Ne 10). Was Jesus visiting other groups during that time who were not related to Nephites? Of course, this is all subjective questioning that none of us can answer.
Another Incan legend, of Tonapa, was an Incan prophet who called the people to repent from worshipping other gods, and to return to worshipping Viracocha alone. His legend states he hung himself on a cross and died singing death songs. This one is more clearly influenced by Christian teaching, as the Spanish author wondered if Tonapa was St Thomas or another apostle.

While the proof is not there of a direct tie, the story shows that ancient Americans did believe in the loss of the Sun for a time, and the return of a white god to the people once the Sun arose.

This suggests that an ancient memory may tie into the Book of Mormon.

Unknown said...

rameumptom:

The tricky thing about using native legends that have been filtered through the Spanish is that you don't know what or how much has been filtered (as you note, there was a general trend to see St. Thomas in many of these legends).

As for the sun being in darkness, that sounds like a pretty standard creation myth. There is no sun and after a ritually appropriate time, the sun arises with a hero-god, or typically because of the hero-god.

Because it could so easily be a native story with just enough twist on it that we see the Book of Mormon in it, we can't do more than say that it is a curiosity. Being from the wrong place and wrong time doesn't help when we try to use it as evidence that happened elsewhere.

Could there have been a connection? Well, maybe. The connection is so tenuous, however, that it is best not to rely upon it.

Unknown said...

Thanks you for this post… great information.
ICC T20 World Cup 2016
Australia vs India time table

Unknown said...

ICC T20 World Cup 2016 Schedule
ICC T20 World Cup 2016 time table
ICC T20 World Cup 2016 live streaming

Unknown said...

Watch ICC t20 world cup 2016 live streaming india vs australia, Live Telecast Of World T20 2016 India, India Vs Pakistan, India Vs Australia Watch Online, T20 World Cup Live Streaming Free.

Unknown said...

New Zealand t20 live streaming
Pakistan t20 live streaming
Australia t20 Live Streaming
South Africa T20 live streaming
india t20 live streaming

seoalivenet said...

Pakistan team T20 world cup 2016
Australia Team t20 world cup 2016
South Africa Team T20 world cup 2016
india team t20 world cup 2016

Unknown said...

nice article................
icc t20 world cup 2016 ceremony
icc t20 world cup 2016 streaming
icc t20 world cup 2016 teams
icc t20 world cup 2016 squads
icc t20 world cup 2016 live score
icc t20 world cup 2016 streaming channels
icc t20 world cup 2016 schedule

Unknown said...

T20Schedule 2016
Samsung galaxy S7
Bekhudi suroor
IPL 2016 Live Streaming

Unknown said...

ICC T20 WORLD CUP 2016 PREDICTION IND VS PAK

ICC T20 WORLD CUP 2016 PREDICTION INDIA VS PAKISTAN

Asia Cup 2016 T20 India Vs Pakistan Match Prediction

t20 updates said...

t20worldcup2016livestreaming
t20worldcup2016
t20worldcup2016streaming
t-20worldcup2016live
Asian cup India vs Pakistan
Asian cup India vs Pakistan
Asian cup India vs Pakistan
Asian cup India vs Pakistan
Asian cup India vs Pakistan

MDSha said...

so great lifeongoldplates website give more info about our lifves
India vs Pakistan world cup t20 live streaming
India vs Pakistan asia cup t20 live streaming
Happy New Year 2017 Wishes
Happy New Year 2017 Wallpaper
Happy New Year 2017 Greetings

Unknown said...

Very True Indeed. Looking forward for more articles like this one. Thanks
http://mahashivratri2016image.in/maha-shivratri-whatsapp-video-wishes-cards-sms-msg/
http://mahashivratri2016image.in/maha-shivratri-special-dj-remix-video-songs-list-collection/
http://mahashivratri2016image.in/maha-shivratri-date-timing-shubh-muhurat-in-2016/
http://holi2016wishes.in/holi-best-easy-and-colorful-rangoli-designs-ideas/
http://holi2016wishes.in/happy-dhulandi-2016-free-wallpapers-images-pictures/
http://holi2016wishes.in/happy-holi-2016-very-funny-cartoon-images-memes-pictures-photos/
http://holi2016wishes.in/free-happy-holi-2016-hd-wallpapers/

Unknown said...

ICC T20 World Cup 2016,ICC T20 World Cup 2016 Teams Squads, ICC T20 World Cup 2016 Live Score, ICC T20 World Cup 2016 Live Streaming ,ICC T20 World Cup 2016 Tickets
ICC T20 World Cup 2016 india match live streaming

ICC T20 World Cup 2016

ICC T20 World Cup 2016,ICC T20 World Cup 2016 Teams Squads, ICC T20 World Cup 2016 Live Score, ICC T20 World Cup 2016 Live Streaming ,ICC T20 World Cup 2016 Tickets
http://www.icct20worldcup2016watchonline.com/

india vs pakistan t20 live steaming 2016

T20 World Cup 2016 Live Streaming

ICC T20 World Cup 2016 Tickets
T20 World Cup 2016 Tickets

Unknown said...

great blog i have every seen keep it up
India vs Pakistan t20 live streaming
India vs New Zealand t20 live streaming
India vs Srilanka asia cup t20 live streaming
India vs Srilanka t20 live streaming
Happy New Year 2017 greetings
Happy New Year 2017 Wallpaper
Happy New Year 2017

Unknown said...

ICC T20 World Cup 2016 Opening Ceremony Tickets & Live Watch Full Performance

Unknown said...

check out..! Here you get the Sp Flash Tools or Sp Flash Tools Links For Download

http://www.spflashtooldownload.com/

Unknown said...

check out ! here you get the best reviews on movies and gadegts by professionals

http://www.trendsreviewer.com/

Anonymous said...


facts such as players and habits
indian team facts

viral news about these match
about india vs pakisthan match

players discussions
facts of pakisthan team

ipl 2016 points table
live match

ipl 2016 points table

Unknown said...

Happy Holi SMS 2016
Happy Holi Quotes 2016
Happy Holi SMS in Hindi
Happy Holi SMS in English
Happy Holi Wishes 2016
Happy Holi Greetings 2016
Happy Holi Date 2016
Happy Holi Whatsaap Status
Happy Holi Facebook Status
Happy Holi Facebook Cover
happy holi 2016 wishes
Happy Holi Recipes
india vs pakistan live
india vs pakistan worldcup
live
t20worldcup live
icc t20worldcup 2016
icc t20worldcup 2016 live
icc t20worldcup highlights
worldcup live
20-20 World Cup 2016 Schedule

Unknown said...

nice article.......
Happy Holi Images 2016
Happy Holi Wallpaper 2016
Happy Holi Photos 2016
Happy Holi Pictures 2016
Happy Holi SMS 2016
Happy Holi Quotes 2016
Happy Holi SMS in Hindi
Happy Holi SMS in English
Happy Holi Wishes 2016
Happy Holi Greetings 2016
T20 Worldcup Live
T20 Worldcup Live Score
Ban vs Ind Live
India vs England Live
England vs India Live
India vs Australia Live
Ind vs Aus Live
ind vs Aus T20 Live
India vs Australia Live 2016
india vs pakistan
india vs pakistan live
ind vs pak Live
ind v pak 2016 Live
Pak vs Ind Live 2016


Unknown said...

Easter Sunday Pictures For Mom

Unknown said...

T20 World Cup 2016 Live Score
T20 World Cup Live Streaming
Today T20 World Cup Live Score
T20 Cup Ball by Ball Score
T20 Cup 2016 Today Live Score


T20 Live Score
T20 World Cup Live Streaming
T20 World Cup Live Scorecard
T20 World Cup Live Scorecard
ICC T20 World Cup 2016 Live Score



IPL 9 Prediction
IPL 2016 Who Will Win
IPL 9 Score Ball by Ball


Today Football Prediction
Today Football Live Score

ajay kumar said...

The article you have shared here very awesome.
Watch IPL cricket live Video streaming
IPL 9 live streaming video
http://www.ipl9live-streaming.in/
ipl 2016 live streaming

http://www.ipl2016schedule.in/ said...

live
ipl 9live
ipl 2016
ipl 2016 live
ipl cup 2016 highlights
ipl matchlive
ipl 2016 Schedule

rajeev tandon said...

Happy Holi Cute Greeting

tiyasharma said...

New Zealand vs India
West Indies vs England
Pakistan v Bangladesh
Sri Lanka v Afghanistan
Australia vs New Zealand
South Africa vs England
India v Pakistan
South Africa v Afghanistan
Sri Lanka v West Indies






tiyasharma said...

Australia v Bangladesh
New Zealand v Afghanistan
India v Afghanistan
Pakistan vs Australia
South Africa v West Indies
Bangladesh v New Zealand
England vs Sri Lanka
India v Australia
Afghanistan v West Indies
South Africa v Sri Lanka
t-20 world cup semi-final
t-20 world cup semi-final
Final

kuku said...

happy birthday images

Megan Valish said...

Happy Holi 2016
Happy Holi 2016 Images
Happy Holi Facebook Status
Happy Holi Greeting
Happy Holi Images
Happy Holi Messages
Happy Holi Pictures
Happy Holi Quotes
Happy Holi Recipes
Happy Holi Shayari
Happy Holi SMS
Happy Holi Song
Happy Holi Wallpapers
Happy Holi Whatsapp Status
Happy Holi Wishes
Holi Celebration 2016
Holi Celebration In India
Whatsapp Holi Wishes
ipl 2016 schedule time table
ipl 2016 teams
ipl 2016 time table
ipl 2016 live streaming
Vivo Ipl 2016
ipl 2016 schedule
Vivo ipl 2016 schedule
Vivo ipl 2016 schedule
IPL Live Streaming
ipl 2016 Live
IPL 2016 Live Match

Unknown said...

Funny Happy Holi Images, Sms, Quotes, Pics And Messages In Hindi

PRINCE said...

Watch Copa America 2016 Live free
UEFA Euro 2016 Full Match Schedule PDF
Rio Olympics Summer Games in Brazil

Unknown said...


Thanks.... This website is very helpful for me... I'm looking this website for a long
IPL t20
IPL t20 2016
IPL t20 2016 live
IPL t20 2016 Live streaming
IPL Live Streaming
IPL Live
IPL t20 2016 Streaming
IPL t20 live Streaming
IPL t20 live
gseb
gseb result
gseb result 2016
maru bharat
maru bharat

icc t20 world cup
icc t20 world cup 2016
icc t20 world cup 2016 live
icc t20 world cup 2016 live streaming
icc t20 world cup live
t20 world cup 2016
t20 world cup
t20 world cup 2016 live
t20 world cup 2016 live streaming
t20 world cup live
rio olympic game 2016
rio olympic schedule 2016
rio olympic games
I'm gonna to share with my friends...

Unknown said...

tamil kavithaigal

BAD MAN said...

I've been browsing online more than three hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It's pretty worth enough for me.
real madrid vs barcelona live streaming
la liga live streaming
el clasico live streaming
french open 2016
roland garros 2016
french open results
roland garros live
french open live
french open schedule
french open live streaming
french open 2016 results
french open live scores
french open 2016 schedule
Ipl live streaming
Ipl live 2016
Ipl live score
Ipl 2016

Megan Valish said...

T20 World Cup Final
England vs Afghanistan
India vs Bangladesh
Online Health Care Tips
IPL 2016 Schedule
Dhoom 4
T20 World Cup 2016
Ipl 2016
Ipl 2016 Schedule
Happy Mothers Day
Happy Mothers Day 2016
IPL 2016 Schedule
IPL 2016 Match
IPL 2016 Draft
IPL 2016 Auction
IPL 2016 Live
VIVO IPL 2016
VIVO IPL 2016 Schedule
ipl 2016 schedule time table
VIVO IPL 2016 Match
VIVO IPL 2016 Draft
VIVO IPL 2016 Auction
VIVO IPL 2016 Live
ipl 2016 Live Streaming
VIVO IPL 2016
VIVO IPL 2016 Live Streaming
ipl 2016 Live
IPL 2016 Live Match
IPL 9 Schedule
IPL 9 Match
ipl 2016 Live Score
IPL 9 Draft
IPL 9 Auction
IPL 9 Live
IPL Live 2016
VIVO IPL 9
ipl 2016 Opening ceremony
VIVO IPL 9 Schedule
VIVO IPL 9 Match
ipl 9 Live Match
ipl 9 Schedule Time table
Vivo ipl live score
VIVO IPL 9 Live
VIVO IPL 9 Live
VIVO IPL 9
VIVO IPL 9 Live Streaming

Megan Valish said...

T20 World Cup Final
England vs Afghanistan
India vs Bangladesh
Online Health Care Tips
IPL 2016 Schedule
Dhoom 4
T20 World Cup 2016
Ipl 2016
Ipl 2016 Schedule
Happy Mothers Day
Happy Mothers Day 2016
IPL 2016 Schedule
IPL 2016 Match
IPL 2016 Draft
IPL 2016 Auction
IPL 2016 Live
VIVO IPL 2016
VIVO IPL 2016 Schedule
ipl 2016 schedule time table
VIVO IPL 2016 Match
VIVO IPL 2016 Draft
VIVO IPL 2016 Auction
VIVO IPL 2016 Live
ipl 2016 Live Streaming
VIVO IPL 2016
VIVO IPL 2016 Live Streaming
ipl 2016 Live
IPL 2016 Live Match
IPL 9 Schedule
IPL 9 Match
ipl 2016 Live Score
IPL 9 Draft
IPL 9 Auction
IPL 9 Live
IPL Live 2016
VIVO IPL 9
ipl 2016 Opening ceremony
VIVO IPL 9 Schedule
VIVO IPL 9 Match
ipl 9 Live Match
ipl 9 Schedule Time table
Vivo ipl live score
VIVO IPL 9 Live
VIVO IPL 9 Live
VIVO IPL 9
VIVO IPL 9 Live Streaming

Devine Bloggers said...

NATIONAL CEREMONY
ACTIVITIES
RACE START TIME

Unknown said...

hsc result 2008
icse 10th board results 2016
india ssc result
sslc results websites
cbse resuls
cinco de mayo meaning in english

Mothersday said...

mother's day,
mothers day quotes,
mothers day images,
mother day,
mother day quotes,
mother day images,
mother's day,
happy mothers day images,
mothers day gifts,
mothers day gift ideas,
mothers day cards,
happy mothers day pictures,
mothers day 2016,
mothers day messages,
happy mothers day,
happy mothers day quotes,
mothers day pictures,
Happy Mothers Day 2016,
Happy Mothers Day Messages,
Happy Mothers Day Shayari,
Happy Mothers Day SMS,
Happy Mothers Day Wishes,
Mothers Day HD Images,
Mothers Day Images,
Mothers Day Images in HD,
Mothers Day Latest Quotes,
Mothers Day latest Shayari,
Mothers Day Latest SMS,
Mothers Day Quotes,
Mothers Day Status,
mothers day pictures,
best mothers day poem 2016,
happy mother day quotes,
happy mother day song,
free mothers day cards,
happy mother day message,
happy mother day wishes,
happy mother day poems,
happy mothers day poems from daughter,
happy mothers day poems deceased mom,
happy mothers day poems for teachers,

adrian said...

Be that as it may, it's somewhat a fun dependence and not exceptionally risky (unless it keeps you from your work). runx

adrian said...

On the off chance that you tend to feel desolate when playing all alone (or you're the aggressive sort), pick multiplayer arcade amusements and offer them with your companions. play here

Unknown said...

I feel that is one of the most important info for me.
And i am glad reading your article. However wanna observation on few general things, The site style is perfect, the articles is actually
excellent : D. Good process, cheers
happy mothers day
happy mothers day picutures 2016
daughter in law poems quotes
happy mothers day quotes from son in hindi
funny mothers day poems
funny mothers day messages

Unknown said...

http://www.lifeongoldplates.com/2008/09/method-and-skepticism-and-quetzalcoatl.html
http://www.lifeongoldplates.com/2008/09/method-and-skepticism-and-quetzalcoatl.html
http://www.mysweetsavannahblog.com/2015/12/knockoff-anthropologie-wreath.html
http://blogdelanine.blogspot.fr/2006/09/studio-friday-floral-treat.html
http://blogdelanine.blogspot.fr/2010/10/chalkboard.html
http://blogdelanine.blogspot.fr/2010/10/chalkboard.html
http://www.two-tarts.com/2011/12/ruby-yacht-cocktail.html
http://www.two-tarts.com/2011/12/ruby-yacht-cocktail.html
http://blog.kazuhooku.com/2014/12/64-bit.html
http://blog.kazuhooku.com/2014/12/64-bit.html
http://thepaintedarea.blogspot.fr/2010/04/painted-areas-2009-10-awards.html
http://thepaintedarea.blogspot.fr/2010/04/painted-areas-2009-10-awards.html
http://www.happyvalentinesday2016quotes.in/2015/12/happy-valentines-day-2016-quotes-wishes.html
http://blog.kazuhooku.com/2014/12/url-ipv6.html
http://blog.kazuhooku.com/2014/12/url-ipv6.html

Unknown said...

http://www.lifeongoldplates.com/2008/09/method-and-skepticism-and-quetzalcoatl.html
http://www.lifeongoldplates.com/2008/09/method-and-skepticism-and-quetzalcoatl.html
http://www.mysweetsavannahblog.com/2015/12/knockoff-anthropologie-wreath.html
http://blogdelanine.blogspot.fr/2006/09/studio-friday-floral-treat.html
http://blogdelanine.blogspot.fr/2010/10/chalkboard.html
http://blogdelanine.blogspot.fr/2010/10/chalkboard.html
http://www.two-tarts.com/2011/12/ruby-yacht-cocktail.html
http://www.two-tarts.com/2011/12/ruby-yacht-cocktail.html
http://blog.kazuhooku.com/2014/12/64-bit.html
http://blog.kazuhooku.com/2014/12/64-bit.html
http://thepaintedarea.blogspot.fr/2010/04/painted-areas-2009-10-awards.html
http://thepaintedarea.blogspot.fr/2010/04/painted-areas-2009-10-awards.html
http://www.happyvalentinesday2016quotes.in/2015/12/happy-valentines-day-2016-quotes-wishes.html
http://blog.kazuhooku.com/2014/12/url-ipv6.html
http://blog.kazuhooku.com/2014/12/url-ipv6.html

Unknown said...


Have you notice the new LG G5 Case ? its awesome

Karan Arora said...

Earth Day Ideas
Earth Day Events
Earth Day Projects

Unknown said...

Thanks for the great post. Want to get funny mothers day quotes? check my blog

Unknown said...

Do you want to know aboutiPhone 8 release date? visit this site

Unknown said...

Do you want to know aboutiPhone 8 release date? visit this site

Unknown said...

Hello dear .You put really very helpful information.
It’s pretty worth enough for me. In my opinion, if all webmasters and bloggers made good content as you did, the web will be a lot more useful than ever before.
ipl live streaming
IPL 2016 Live Streaming
IPL Live Streaming 2016
ipl cricket live streaming
IPL 9 Live Streaming
ipl live streaming
IPL 2016 Live Streaming
IPL Live Streaming 2016
ipl cricket live streaming
IPL 9 Live Streaming

nazima said...

Cbse North Region 10th Results
Cbse Haryana 10th Results
Cbse Chennai 10th Results

Unknown said...

mother day message
mother's day messages
mothers day messages

Amit Agrwal said...

Earth Day clip art

Unknown said...

poetry on mother
Mothers Day Unique Cards
Mother day card
Mothers Day Unique Sayings

Aliya said...

mother's day in heaven quotes

Sikha Vashisht said...

copa américa centenario 2016

copa libertadores 2016 fixture
copaamerica2016schedule
fixtures copa america


Costa Rica 2016 Kits
Argentina Copa America 2016 Squad
Bolivia Copa America 2016 Squad
Brazil Copa America 2016 Squad
Chile Copa America 2016 Squad
Colombia Copa America 2016 Squad
Costa Rica Copa America 2016 Squad
Ecuador Copa America 2016 Squad
Haiti Copa America 2016 Squad
Jamaica Copa America 2016 Squad
Mexico Copa America 2016 Squad
Panama Copa America 2016 Squad
Paraguay Copa America 2016 Squad
Peru Copa America 2016 Squad
United States Copa America 2016 Squad
Uruguay Copa America 2016 Squad
Venezuela Copa America 2016 Squad
Mothers Day 2016
Mothers Day 2016 Images
Mothers Day Printable Sheets
Mothers Day
Mothers Day Images Download
Mothers Day Quotes Images
Mothers Day 2016 Quotes
Mothers Day SMS
Mothers Day Images For Whatsapp
Mothers Day Images For Facebook
Mothers Day 2016 Hd Images
WhatsApp Message Status
Mothers Day 2016

Unknown said...

www.memorialdayimages-2016.com

Unknown said...

high scores on piano tiles

Unknown said...

Fathers Day Pics
Father's Day Best Messages
happy Father's Day Top Quotes 2016
Father's Day Pics

Unknown said...

Father's Day Gifts
2016 Fathers Day Wishes
Father’s Day Quotes
2016 Fathers Day Quotes

Unknown said...

Father's Day sayings
Father's Day Lovely Quotes

Fathers Day Best Poems
2016 Father's Day Pics

mkkk said...

world environment day slogans
world environment day
world environment day slogans in english
world environment day essay
world environment day speech
world environment day speech for students
world environment day speech in hindi
world environment day 2016
world environment day 2016 theme
why we celebrate world environment day

Anonymous said...

HOW TO BECOME UBER PARTNER AND DRIVERS ?

Slither.io Tips Tricks and Lag Fix

http://techilite.com/

Unknown said...

mehndi design for hands
designer blouses
mehendi
new mehndi design
boat neck blouse designs
latest mehndi design
blouses designs
mehndi designs images
bridal blouse designs
bridal mehndi designs
saree blouse designs
latest mehndi designs
neck designs
mehandi images
boat neck
mehandi designs for hands

Unknown said...

Happy Fathers Day Picture
Happy Fathers Day 2016
Happy Fathers Day Wishes
Happy Fahters Day Wishes
Happy Fathers Day Wallpaper
Fathers Day 2016 Quotes
Fathers Day Images
Happy Fathers Day Cards
Father's Day Greetings
Happy Father’s Day Messages
Father's Day Cards

Unknown said...

The discussion was very interesting to read, nice article, its content is very good and interesting.
Halloween 2016 Costumes Ideas
Happy Diwali 2016 Images
Get Passport Status
Check Passport Status
When Halloween 2016
Black Friday 2016 Deals
Veg Food Recipe
Ganesh Chaturthi 2016 Images
Independence Day 2016
Latest Government Jobs
Champions Trophy 2017 Schedule
2017 Champions Trophy
Whatsapp Status Image
Euro 2016 Semi Final
Euro 2016 Final
Euro 2016 Quarter Final
copa america 2016 semifinal
USA vs Argentina semi final
Copa America 2016 Final
4th Of July
Happy 4th Of July
Happy Independence Day Usa
Fourth Of July Quotes
4th Of July Fireworks
Happy Independence Day
Happy Independence Day Wishes
Happy Independence Day Quotes
Happy Independence Day Images
Happy Independence Day Fireworks
Bigg Boss Season 10
IPL 2017 Schedule
Fifa World Cup 2018 schedule

Shuruti said...

Five Fourth Of July Decoration Ideas With Crafts
4th Of July Activities, Fireworks
Fourth Of July Greetings, Ecards
Independence Day Quotes, Messages And Pictures
Happy 4th Of July Parades, Cliparts And Decorations

Unknown said...

Independence Day Quotes
Happy Independence Day Cards
Happy Independence Day Songs
Happy Independence Day 2016
Happy Independence Day Greetings

Anonymous said...

United States Independence day is not just a great event but it Independence Day Verses is also a great opportunity of making special and sweet memories with your Fellow Americans. USA Independence Day Images On United States Independence day people have the great chance of making special memories with their fellow

vishal said...

Happy Independence Day
4th Of July Nails Crafts Decorations Cake Outfits
4th Of July Wallpapers
Happy 4th Of July Quotes
4th Of July Activities
Happy independence Day Inspirational Quotes Sayings

Team Plus India said...

best quality flats in
faridabad

residental property in gurgaon
2 bhk flats in gurgaon
best flats in faridabad
ready to move in flats in gurgaon
commercial property in gurgaon
ready to move in flats in faridabad
ready to move flats in delhi ncr
friendship day 2016 images
friendship day 2016 images pictures
friendship day images
friendship day 2016 images for fb whatsapp

Unknown said...

Nice Article , I also have some topics visit them..............
Happy Friendship Day
Happy Friendship Day Quotes
Friendship Day Quotes
Friendship Day Images
Friendship Day Messages
Friendship Day SMS
Best Whatsapp Status
15th August Whatsapp Status
Friendship Day Whatsapp Status
Friendship Whatsapp Status
Happy Friendship Day Whatsapp Status
Happy Independence Day Whatsapp Status
Love Status for Whatsapp
Nice Whatsapp Status
Happy Birthday Whatsapp Status
Funny Whatsapp Status
Cool Whatsapp Status
Good Morning Whatsapp Status
Good Night Whatsapp Status
Best Whatsapp DP
Whatsapp Profile Picture
Parents Day Whatsapp Status
Happy Parents Day
Raksha Bandhan Whatsapp Status
Happy Raksha Bandhan Status
Rakhi Whatsapp Status

Unknown said...

Nice Article , I also have some topics visit them..............
Happy Raksha Bandhan
Happy Raksha Bandhan Images
Happy Raksha Bandhan Wishes
Rakhi Images
Raksha Bandhan
Raksha Bandhan 2016
Raksha Bandhan Greetings
Raksha Bandhan Images
Raksha Bandhan Messages
Raksha Bandhan Photos
Raksha Bandhan Pics
Raksha Bandhan Pictures
Raksha Bandhan SMS
Raksha Bandhan Status
Raksha Bandhan Wallpaper
Raksha Bandhan Wishes
Janmashtami Images
Happy Janmashtami
Krishna Janmashtami
Krishna Janmashtami 2016
Krishna Janmashtami Celebration
Krishna Janmashtami Facebook Status
Krishna Janmashtami Images
Krishna Janmashtami Messages
Krishna Janmashtami Photos
Krishna Janmashtami Pics
Krishna Janmashtami Pictures
Krishna Janmashtami Quotes
Krishna Janmashtami SMS
Krishna Janmashtami Wallpaper
Krishna Janmashtami Whatsapp Status
Krishna Janmashtami Wishes

Unknown said...

Great post! I am actually getting ready to go across, this post is very informative. By the way, Get
Happy Friendship Day Images
http://www.inspirationallovequotesimages.com/2015/10/happy-new-year-2016-quotes.html
http://www.birthdaywishesquotes.org/2016/02/happy-birthday-quotes.html
pokemon go apk
kris jenner instagram
teachers day quotes
Christmas Love Quotes
Acceptance Quotes

Amar said...

really aweeome news..
Krishna Pushkaralu in Telangana
NIMCET 2017
JEE Mains results 2017
AP EAMCET 2017 Application form
JEE Mains 2017 Notification
neet 2016 results

Unknown said...

nice post
independence day shayari in hindi
Information about independence day in english
thoughts on independence day in hindi

Anonymous said...

SEO Agency
Licensed Money Lender
Personal Loan

Christian Bale said...

Nice looking site.really appreciate for it and It is also useful for me.Thank you for sharing.
happy friendship day 2016
Happy new year
Romantic Quotes
merry christmas messages
pokemon go apk
Teachers Day Poems

Anonymous said...

Friends are the most valuable gift of god in our life Friendship Day Lines For Friends Friendship is the only relation where blood relation does not exist nor its matter. We should always understand the importance of friendship without misunderstanding them.

Anonymous said...

Very Nice Post.

Credit Companies in Singapore

Unknown said...

happy friendship day messages

Happy Friendshipday 2016 funny wishes , happy friendship day sms


Friendship Day Wallpapers


Happy friendship day wishes cards greetings download



friendship day quotes and sayings

Best Happy Friendship Day Quotes for Facebook

happy friendship day wishes quotes


Happy Friendship Day Messages happy friendship day wishes

happy friendship day wishes

Happy Friendship Day Facebook Timeline Images, FB Cover Photos 2016

Happy Friendship Day 2016


Friendship Day 2016

Anonymous said...

We celebrate friendship day on 1st Sunday of August Happy Friendship Day Messages Friendship is a faithful and loyal relationship between two or more person living anywhere in the world.

Unknown said...

Happy Birthday Cards
Happy Birthday Pictures

good morning sms
good morning image
images of good morning

Anonymous said...

Nice Post.
Cash Advance Payday Loans

Dubai VIsa said...

Overnight Desert Safari Dubai

Dubai Visa from India

manish said...

Hi i was browsing your blog and i found it really interesting! i too have a website.Kindly check it out here
New Whatsapp Status
Whatsapp Status
Best Whatsapp Status
Funny Whatsapp Status
Cool Whatsapp Status
Latest Whatsapp Status
Love Whatsapp Status
Best Status for Whatsapp
Funny Status for Whatsapp
Love Status for Whatsapp
Best Status for Whatsapp
Cool Status for Whatsapp
New Status For Whatsapp
Happy Ganesh Chaturthi Status For Whatsapp
Happy Ganesh Chaturthi Status For Facebook
Ganesh Chaturthi Whatsapp Status
Ganesh Chaturthi Facebook Status
Ganesh Chaturthi Facebook Messages
Ganesh Chaturthi Images
Ganesh Chaturthi Messages
Ganesh Chaturthi Pictures
Ganesh Chaturthi Whatsapp Status
Ganesh Chaturthi Wishes
Ganpati Bappa Moriya


Unknown said...

I found your blog using msn. This is an extremely well written article. I will be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful information. Thanks for the post. I’ll certainly comeback

Andhra Pradesh SSC results 2017
AP 10th results 2017
AP EAMCET Results Date
AP EAMCET Results 2017
TS SSC results 2017

sweet dreem sms said...

Eid Mubarak SMS in Hindi most recent of 2017 which can’t be discovered anyplace on net. You can

duplicate these Eid SMS and send to your Parents, Relatives and companions.
Eid mubarak cards
eidimages

roy sam said...

It's interesting.Thanks for sharing! montana scholarship details., Internet Marketing Scholarship

Cricket Highlights said...

A normal game of cricket can last for some hours while Test cricket can last for days. Online cricket game on the other hand, is confined to just few minutes or maximum an hour. The main necessary equipments in this game of cricket are- Cricket Ball, Cricket Bat, Wickets, Stumps, and Watch Online Score At cricketgames.

wajahat said...

Free Fb hacks

bilal said...

All Sports Updates Visit Here
All Sports Updates Visit Here

wajahat said...

Updates About Wrestling Visit
wrestle-mania

user123 said...

And indeed, I’m just always astounded concerning the remarkable things served by you. Some four facts on this page are undeniably the most effective I’ve had.
Data science Training in Chennai | No.1 Data Science Training in Chennai
RPA Training in Chennai | No.1 RPA Training in Chennai
AWS Training in Chennai | No.1 AWS Training in Chennai
Devops Training in Chennai | Best Devops Training in Chennai
Selenium Training in Chennai | Best Selenium Training in Chennai
Java Training in Chennai | Best Java Training in Chennai

Riyas Fathin said...

I believe there are many more pleasurable opportunities ahead for individuals that looked at your site.
MATLAB TRAINING IN CHENNAI | BEST MATLAB TRAINING IN CHENNAI
EMBEDDED SYSTEMS TRAINING IN CHENNAI | BEST EMBEDDED TRAINING IN CHENNAI | EMBEDDED SYSTEMS COURSE IN CHENNAI
MCSA / MCSE TRAINING IN CHENNAI | BEST MCSE TRAINING IN CHENNAI | MCSE COURSE IN CHENNAI
CCNA TRAINING IN CHENNAI | BEST CCNA TRAINING IN CHENNAI | CCNA COURSE IN CHENNAI
ANDROID TRAINING IN CHENNAI | BEST ANDROID TRAINING IN CHENNAI | ANDROID COURSE IN CHENNAI

atup said...

Want your NFT development process to be fast and seamless? Get complete assistance with hosting and documentation only with CronJ. Our NFT development services provide smart contract automation, audits, and development services to help protect you and your company. Together we’ll build an efficient and error-free nft development platform that helps protect your NFT transactions.

quickbooks tool hub download said...

Hi, this is Edward Pattinson working as a QuickBooks technician for many years. if you wanted to setup quickbooks bank feeds problems and you don't know how to deal with them, I am here to solve your issues, I am working with QuickBooks for many years, on how to set up QB bank feed issues & create rules to help QuickBooks match your Bank Feed transactions.

shivani said...

TrackoBit is a telematics software company, based in India that specializes in fleet management software. It is designed to help businesses with vehicles, such as fleets of trucks or delivery vehicles, manage and track their assets in real-time. This can include features such as vehicle tracking Software, route optimization, fuel management, and maintenance scheduling, among others.

Armanunderpin said...

It's like you opened a door to a world where mythology and skepticism dance hand in hand.
The way you connected Quetzalcoatl with different philosophical schools, especially the Socratic method, was mind-blowing.
biggest waterfall in the world

Post a Comment

All views are welcome when shared respectfully. Use a name or consistent pseudonym rather than "anonymous." Deletions of inflammatory posts will be noted. Thanks for joining the conversation.